It’s time to talk about the indie horror phenomenon that has everyone reeling. This week, we’re dissecting 2026’s Obsession—a film that proves you don’t need a massive studio budget to create a masterclass in psychological dread and toxic masculinity. We’re joined by the returning Jordan the Grey Witch to break down why this movie is hitting so hard, its problematic production history, and the terrifying performance that should be dominating awards season.
Guest: Jordan the Grey Witch
We are thrilled to have back our resident horror expert, Jordan the Grey Witch. You can follow her latest deep dives on YouTube and keep up with her takes on Bluesky.
What We Cover
- Behind the Scenes: The Art Director Pay Controversy
- The Real Villain: Bear’s Nice-Guy Entitlement
- The Wish Stick: MacGuffin Logic & Rules
- Holy Sh*t Moments: Our Favorite Scenes
- Nikki vs. Pearl: Comparing Horror’s Best Unhinged Performances
This film is a visceral gut-punch that explores the dark side of obsession. Brian and John get deep into why “Bear” is perhaps the most insufferable protagonist we’ve encountered in years—and why his “nice guy” facade is the true catalyst for the carnage. We also debate the ethics of the film’s production, specifically the controversy surrounding crew pay, and discuss whether the film’s “wish stick” lore holds up to scrutiny.
SPOILER WARNING: We dive deep into the ending of Obsession, so make sure you’ve watched the film before hitting play!
Verdict: Obsession is a must-watch indie masterpiece that reminds us exactly why we love the genre: it’s raw, unflinching, and willing to go where the big-budget tentpoles are too terrified to tread. 🔪
Listen now at cinemapsychoshow.com/follow! 🎧
Next time on the show: We’re pivoting to the frozen tundra for a retrospective on Fargo (1996).